Brooklyn Bedding vs Tuft & Needle: Which Should You Get?

Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle are two great companies that have leveraged the online-only business model to great success.  While they have a similar business model, there are clear differences between the two mattresses. We’ll compare these mattresses so you can make the choice between Brooklyn Bedding vs Tuft & Needle.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft & Needle

Product

Firmness

Score

Product

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress

Firmness

Multiple firmness options

Score

4.0 / 5

Check Price

Read Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress Review

Product

Tuft & Needle Mattress

Firmness

Medium-firm: 6.5/10

Score

3.6 / 5

Check Price

Read Tuft & Needle Mattress Review

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft & Needle: Overview

The differences are stark enough that if you understand them, you should be able to make a clear choice as to which will be best for you. Hopefully this article will help you if you are making the decision of Brooklyn Bedding vs Tuft & Needle.

Key Similarities

• Both have a similar business model (online-only) and both contain foam only
• Both include free shipping and arrive in a box
• Both companies are known for their customer service and have return policies and trial periods that are very generous for consumers
• Both mattresses have the same thickness (10”)

Key Differences

• Brooklyn Bedding is $150 more expensive (exclusive of any discounts from either company) but also more durable.
• Tuft & Needle has one firmness option; Brooklyn Bedding has three
• The comfort layer of Tuft & Needle is specialty polyfoam, while the Brooklyn Bedding has all-latex
• The Brooklyn Bedding is bouncier/more resilient and more durable overall

Construction and Feel

The Tuft And Needle consists of 3” of a 2.8 lb. density specialty polyfoam over 7” of 1.8 lb. density polyfoam (learn more in my full Tuft and Needle review). Tuft & Needle Mattress The Brooklyn Bedding #bestmattressever has 2” of talalay latex, over 2” of dunlop latex, over 6” of high-density polyfoam. Brooklyn Bedding Mattress The support layer of each mattress is very similar. The real difference comes in the comfort layer. Brooklyn Bedding’s two latex layers make it very resilient and bouncy. It sleeps cool and you feel like you are sleeping “on” the mattress rather than “in” the mattress. The polyfoam layer of Tuft & Needle is less bouncy and I feel that you sink into it just a bit more. It sleeps fairly cool as well. I feel the firmness level of the medium Brooklyn Bedding is just a tad bit softer than the Tuft & Needle (but that is subjective). See the feel and firmness of Brooklyn Bedding (medium firmness option) Compared to the feel and firmness of Tuft and Needle

Price

For a Queen mattress, the #bestmattressever is $750.  This is before a typically available 5% discount.  A Tuft & Needle Queen mattress is $600 and there typically is no discount. Both have free shipping. Given the price difference, the main question is whether the additional cost is worth the difference in quality in materials. It may be helpful to see how these prices stack up to others. Make sure to check out our other popular Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle comparisons such as Brooklyn Bedding vs Loom & Leaf and Tuft & Needle vs Puffy.

Pick Brooklyn Bedding If:

• You Have Unique Sleep Preferences– Brooklyn Bedding offers three firmness options, which means that if people are extra heavy or extra light, or if they have unique sleeping circumstances, they may want the option of a soft or firm mattress.
• You Want Bounce– There is no question the Brooklyn Bedding mattress is the bouncier of the two.  If someone wants that bouncy, latex feel, it’s definitely the mattress they should choose.
• You Have a Bit More in Your Budget– Subjectively, I feel the materials in the Brooklyn Bedding are a bit more high-quality, so if people have some room in their budget, then it may be the choice for them.

Get the Best Discount Available on Brooklyn Bedding HERE

Pick Tuft & Needle If:

• You Want to Save- The price difference is fairly significant for some people.  If someone doesn’t plan on having the mattress forever and wants to save a bit of money in the meantime, then Tuft & Needle may be the way to go.
• You Want a More Typical, Balanced Foam Feel- If someone wants a more balanced, typical foam feel where they sink in a little bit and don’t have too much bounce, then the Tuft and Needle might be better for them.

Get the Best Deal on Tuft & Needle HERE

Overall

Personally, I prefer Brooklyn Bedding, but I am a latex mattress fan, and would be willing to spend more for the mattress. I still think Tuft & Needle is a great mattress, especially considering the price.