Written by Tony Klespis, Staff Writer
If you’ve been getting most of your bedding online, chances are you’ve seen Brooklinen around. This popular brand makes a number of bedding products, but if you’re looking for a new comforter, the Brooklinen Down Alternative could be your next bedding upgrade.
In my unbiased review, I tested the Brooklinen down alternative comforter to help out those who might be skeptical before clicking “check out.” I’ll go over my testing experience, which includes napping with it, and I’ll go over the materials Brooklinen uses, break down the price and more.
Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter
If you want a comforter for all occasions, Brooklinen offers a fluffy, cozy, all-season comforter. For those looking for some temperature control, you can get a lightweight or extra-warm option!
Mattress Clarity Score
4.50 / 5
Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter Overview
Here at Mattress Clarity, we love Brooklinen products. The bedding company makes a number of sheet sets like the Classic, Luxe and Linen sheet sets. Brooklinen also produces the adjustable Marlow pillow, which we’ve also reviewed before.
Brooklinen makes a down comforter, but for those who want a hypoallergenic option, you can get the down alternative comforter. Check out my Brooklinen down alternative overview below to help you decide if this is the right comforter for you.
Overall Rating
| Who Might Like the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter? | Who Might Not Like the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter? |
|---|---|
| People looking for warmth options | People who want machine-washable comforters |
| People who prefer cotton comforters | People looking for color options |
| Anyone wanting a comforter to double as a duvet insert | Fans of bamboo comforters |
Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter Materials
Let’s go over the high-quality materials that Brooklinen uses for its down alternative comforter to give you an idea of how this comforter will perform.
Cover
On the outside of the comforter, Brooklinen uses a 100% cotton shell. The cotton fabric has been woven with a sateen weave, which gives this cotton shell a really soft, smooth texture and feel. It won’t feel very crisp or rustle loudly when you move it.
The cover is sewn through with a baffle box construction. This means that the cotton shell is sewn all the way through into a square pattern. Baffle box constructions are common for comforters, as it helps keep the inner fill evenly distributed and prevents clumping.
The Brooklinen down alternative comforter can act as a comforter on its own, but for those who want to add some color (the comforter only comes in white), there are corner loops that allow this to act as a duvet insert.
Fill
Within the cotton shell, Brooklinen has a down alternative fluff. This fluff is made from recycled plastic bottles, making it a fairly eco-friendly option. Even with this in mind, the fill feels very fluffy, soft and lightweight.
Warmth
Brooklinen offers this comforter in three different warmth options: lightweight, all-season and ultra-warm. For this review, I received the all-season, so that’s what I’ll base this section on. Just know that the warmth will change depending on what you choose.
The all-season model is intended for year-round use, but when I tested this comforter, the added warmth was noticeable. It wasn’t so hot and stuffy that I was kicking it off. But if you’re a hot sleeper, or live in a hot climate, I wouldn’t recommend this comforter.
Allergies/Allergens?
Brooklinen does list the down alternative comforter as a hypoallergenic product. This is because of the recycled material for the fill. It won’t trap allergens in your sleep environment, nor should it trigger any allergies. The cotton shell should feel soft and smooth on sensitive skin as well.
30-60 Min Nap with the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter
As a hot sleeper, I tend to only use comforters in the wintertime. I also live in Texas, and at the time of testing this comforter, Austin experienced over 30 consecutive days of temperatures over 100 degrees. So, not the most ideal time to test a comforter.
But napping with the Brooklinen down alternative comforter wasn’t as hot and stuffy as I was anticipating it to be. I spent closer to an hour with this comforter. Though I have the all-season model, the added warmth was noticeable. But I never found myself wanting to kick off the comforter.
This comforter has a good amount of fluff in it, but it didn’t feel particularly heavy. I really enjoyed how soft and smooth the cotton shell felt, too. It made sleeping with it very cozy. I think if I were to use a comforter year-round, I would have needed the lightweight model. The all-season was good for a quick nap, but I couldn’t sleep with it on a regular basis.
Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter Size & Price Chart
Take a look at our chart below for up-to-date pricing information on the Brooklinen down alternative comforter. Note that Brooklinen sells this comforter in three different warmth options, which will change the price. For our chart, I’ve listed the prices for the all-season model, which is the model that I tested.
Also,the prices do not reflect any discounts.
| Size | Price |
| Twin/Twin XL | $199 |
| Full/Queen | $259 |
| King/California king | $309 |
Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter
If you want a comforter for all occasions, Brooklinen offers a fluffy, cozy, all-season comforter. For those looking for some temperature control, you can get a lightweight or extra-warm option!
Mattress Clarity Score
4.50 / 5
Caring for the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter
Brooklinen does not recommend machine-washing the down alternative comforter. Instead, the brand recommends spot cleaning or dry cleaning when accidents happen. However, if you want to protect the comforter, adding a machine-washable duvet cover is an option.
For spot cleaning, Brooklinen doesn’t offer any specific instructions, but the brand does make a point to tell customers to avoid using bleach. Do not iron the comforter either.
How Does the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter Compare to Other Comforters?
If you’re torn between a few different comforters, comparison shopping is always a good idea. Comforters are made with a lot of materials, so let’s compare the Brooklinen down alternative comforter to a bamboo comforter from Nolah and a luxurious silk comforter from Nest Bedding.
Brooklinen vs Nolah
Nolah makes a number of bamboo bedding products, and the brand’s comforter is also made entirely of bamboo. From the outer cover to the inner fill, Nolah uses high-quality, silky-feeling bamboo viscose. This type of comforter will perform differently than the Brooklinen comforter.
The Brooklinen down alternative comforter comes in three different warmth options, while Nolah only offers one warmth option. The Nolah comforter is thin and not very fluffy, and in combination with its breathability and moisture-wicking properties, it’s a better fit for hot sleepers who want something thicker than a top sheet to sleep with year-round.
But if you want a fluffy, cozy-feeling comforter, the Brooklinen down alternative comforter will work much better, so opt for the all-season or ultra-warm models. Plus, the Brooklinen comforter has a more recognizable cotton feel, which might be a better option if you’re not used to the silky feeling of bamboo.
| Who Should Get the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter? | Who Should Get the Nolah Bamboo Comforter? |
| Fans of cotton comforters | Hot sleepers |
| People who want warmth options or thick, fluffy comforters | People who prefer thin, lightweight comforters |
Read our full Nolah Bamboo comforter review.
Brooklinen vs Nest
The Nest Silk Cloud comforter uses Mulberry silk fibers for the inner fill, which are encased in a cotton shell. This comforter is much thinner and more lightweight than the all-season model of the Brooklinen comforter. If you prefer something thick and fluffy, opt for the Brooklinen comforter.
However, thanks to the thinness and silk’s ability to be temperature regulating, the Nest Silk Cloud comforter will be a better choice for people who run hot or live in warm climates. The silk fill certainly makes this comforter more of an investment, but silk fibers are very durable. With good care, the Nest Silk Cloud comforter should last you several years.
But if you want a cozy comforter and are shopping on a budget, the Brooklinen comforter is a good deal more affordable than the Nest comforter.
| Who Should Get the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter? | Who Should Get the Nest Silk Cloud Comforter? |
| Fans of thick, fluffy comforters | Hot sleepers |
| Budget-minded shoppers | People looking for a long-lasting comforter |
Read our Nest Silk Cloud comforter review.
Company Policies for the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter
Here’s what Brooklinen offers on all purchases.:
Warranty
The Brooklinen down alternative comforter comes with a one-year warranty. For more details on the warranty, be sure to read the information on Brooklinen’s website.
Shipping Information
Brooklinen offers free shipping on all orders. However, returns or exchanges are subject to a $9.95 shipping fee and will be deducted from the refund.
Trial Period
The Brooklinen down alternative Comforter comes with a 365-day trial period. This gives you up to a year to decide if this is the right comforter for you. Returns and exchanges can be made during this time, as well.
Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter FAQs
How do you wash a down alternative comforter from Brooklinen?
Unfortunately, the down alternative comforter is not machine-washable. Brooklinen recommends spot cleaning or dry cleaning. But Brooklinen mentions that dry cleaning might decrease the lifespan of the comforter.
How long will the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter last?
Around three to four years. Brooklinen offers a one year-warranty in addition to the 365 day trial period. With good care, the comforter should last at least the warranty, and will last much longer with good care.
Does a down alternative comforter need to go in a duvet cover?
No, it doesn’t. However, many comforters double as duvet inserts these days. Brooklinen makes its down alternative comforter with corner loops so you can attach duvet covers to help it last longer or add some color. Brooklinen also sells duvet covers, but be sure to check out our list of the best duvet covers for more options.
