Mattress Protectors: Fitted Vs. Encasement

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site. See our disclosure page for more information.

If you are in the market for a new mattress protector, you will notice that you have many options. Not only do mattress protectors come in different sizes, materials and offer special functionality – the also fit your mattress differently.

There are two very popular styles of protectors: Fitted and Encasement.

Fitted

Fitted style mattress protectors offer five-sided mattress protection and go on just like a fitted sheet.

Popular (and more affordable) fitted sheet protectors like Hanna Kay, Luna and SafeRest, all offer waterproof and breathable cotton terry surface materials surrounded by a polyester edging.

Hanna Kay Premium Mattress Protector Review
Hanna Kay fitted protector

Many brands offer waterproof options but limit the waterproof area to the top surface of the mattress protector.

Purple’s mattress protector is another great waterproof fitted mattress protector that is 100% waterproof on all sides.

Purple Mattress Protector Review
Purple fitted mattress protector

People tend to like the fitted sheet style mattress protector because it is easy to get on and off the mattress. People can simply pull it off like a fitted sheet and they can throw it in the washing machine.

This style tends to be good for those who need to wash their protectors frequently.

Encasement

Encasement mattress protectors have six-sided protection and completely cover the entire mattress (including the bottom).

Sleep Defense System Mattress Protector Review
Sleep Defense System encasement protector

Many encasement mattress protectors can be zippered shut and completely sealed off with various lock mechanisms.

These protectors are great for people who suffer from allergies or are concerned about bed bugs.

Protectors like the Protect-A-Bed AllerZip protector are lab tested and Certified Allergy & Asthma friendly.

Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Protector Review
Protect-A-Bed AllerZip encasement protector

Similarly, the Sleep Defense System protector can be sealed off and protect the mattress completely from bed bugs. Anyone who has to deal with bed bugs knows it can be costly and time-consuming – making it all the more worth it to investment in an encasement protector.

People May Choose…

Fitted:

  • People want a simple protector that will keep the surface of the mattress free from liquids, dust, and allergens
  • People want a protector that is easy to get on and off the mattress
CasperProtectorReviewSide
Casper fitted mattress protector

Encasement

  • People need a protector that is made specifically to keep dust, allergens and other allergens away from their protector entirely.
  • People need a protector that will ensure their mattress is free from bed bugs
  • People have large spills or accidents that could spill over the top of their mattress and onto the sides

RELATED: Best Mattress Protectors

What To Consider

No matter which protector you pick, there are two things to keep in consideration:

  • A close fit on a mattress protector is essential to a good night’s sleep and a good overall experience. Too much extra material and you will feel the protector, as well as shift and general noise underneath your sheets.
  • Always follow the care instructions on your protector carefully. This is especially important with waterproof protectors – if you dry them on a high heat setting you run the risk of disrupting the waterproof membranes and inviting leaks to seep into your mattress.

Luna Premium Mattress Protector

Subscribe to Mattress Clarity!

Get special coupons, discounts, and giveaways!

Katie Golde

Katie Golde

Senior Digital Content Manager/Managing Editor​

About Author

Katie Golde is a Certified Sleep Science Coach and previously served Managing Editor and Head of Sleep Research for Mattress Clarity. She handled the daily operations of the site and you’ll still see her in plenty of reviews, from mattresses to travel pillow and bed pillow reviews – plus the occasional How-To video. In addition, Katie reported, writed, and edited sleep health and sleep industry news for the site.

Since joining the Mattress Clarity team in 2016, she has reviewed hundreds of sleep products, like bed pillows and mattresses and written over 200 sleep-related stories for the site. She probably knows more about bamboo sheets and bed pillows than any one person should.

Katie has been writing about wellness-related topics, including sleep, for the last eight years. The first sleep story she wrote covered the best and worst foods to eat before bed. Her previous work can be found in print and online publications like Discover Magazine, USA Today, Bustle and The Huffington Post.

She has a bachelor’s degree in Sociology from Northwestern University and a master’s degree in Journalism with a focus on Interactive Publishing from Northwestern’s Medill School of Journalism as well. During her graduate studies, Katie focused on health and science reporting and she received the G.D. Crain Award for demonstrating leadership, management, and entrepreneurial excellence during her final innovation project.

Education & Credentials