Best Customizable Mattresses 2024

Written by Marten Carlson, Lead Mattress and Sleep Product Reviewer

Methodology

Our team of Certified Sleep Science Coaches have reviewed 600+ mattresses and accessories for over seven years using proprietary analysis and hands-on testing. We assess each bed for support, cooling, firmness, pressure relief, and more.

Learn more.

In This Roundup

We’ll be discussing our top picks for the best customizable mattresses with special consideration for firmness options, cooling features, and sizes available.

»

When someone is looking for a new mattress, there is so much to keep in mind – sleeping position, body weight, temperature – the list goes on and on. Just spending five minutes online, there are hundreds of mattresses to choose from. Which mattress will actually meet your specific needs?

Well, the answer could be a customizable mattress. A customizable mattress allows shoppers to choose the firmness, temperature, or feel of their mattress. Basically, you get to have it your way. Read on to find the best customizable mattress.

Our Verdict: What’s the Best Customizable Mattress?

Our expert reviewers chose the Helix Midnight as the best customizable mattress. Helix offers many different mattress models, and there helpful quiz makes it a breeze to find the ideal one for you.

The 6 Best Customizable Mattresses of 2024

• Best Customizable Hybrid Mattress – Helix Midnight
• Best Customizable Mattress for Hot Sleepers – Brooklyn Bedding Custom Mattress
• Best Mattress With Adjustable Firmness – Saatva Solaire
• Best Cooling Mattress – Eight Sleep Pod Pro
• Best Organic Customizable Mattress – PlushBeds Botanical Bliss
• Best Mattress With Firmness Options – Amerisleep AS3

These mattresses are customizable in a number of ways, so keep reading to find out how they work.

Compare the Best Customizable Mattresses

	Helix Midnight Mattress	Brooklyn Bedding Custom Mattress	Saatva Mattress	Eight Sleep Pod Pro Mattress	PlushBeds Botanical Bliss Mattress	Amerisleep AS3 Mattress
Rating	4.1	4.0	4.3	3.6	4.1	4.1
Firmness	Medium-firm: 7/10	Multiple firmness options	Multiple firmness options	Medium-firm: 6.5/10	Multiple firmness options	Medium-firm: 6.5/10
Material	Hybrid	Hybrid	Innerspring	Foam	Latex	Foam
Cooling	—					—
Best For	Couples, Back Sleepers, Side Sleepers	Side Sleepers, Back Sleepers, Stomach Sleepers	Back Sleepers, Stomach Sleepers, Back Pain	Back Sleepers, Stomach Sleepers, Hot Sleepers	Hot Sleepers, Back Sleepers, Stomach Sleepers	Back Sleepers, Side Sleepers, Stomach Sleepers
	Check Price	Check Price	Check Price	Check Price	Check Price	Check Price

How We Chose Our Top Picks for the Best Customizable Mattresses

Our team of Certified Sleep Science Coaches has reviewed more than 600 mattresses, using proprietary analysis and hands-on testing to establish easy-to-understand scores. In addition to an overall score, we measure subscores for support, edge support, cooling, motion transfer, durability, trial period, and warranty.

To narrow our list down to only the best customizable mattresses, we looked for features like firmness selection, sizing options, and cooling properties. This article includes a range of price points to fit any budget and a variety of unique features.

Best Customizable Mattress with Adjustable Firmness – Saatva Solaire

Pros of the Saatva Solaire

50 precise firmness settings

Adjustable firmness on both sides of the bed in queen size mattresses and larger

Excellent motion isolation

Cons of the Saatva Solaire

Lacks support for side sleepers weighing more than 230 lbs

Doesn’t dissipate body heat exceptionally well

High price point

Firmness is one of the main things to consider when choosing a new mattress. With most mattresses, once it’s at your house, that’s how firm it is going to be for quite a while. This is not the case with the Saatva Solaire, a high-end mattress with adjustable firmness.

The Saatva Solaire works by way of air chambers in its support layer. Basically, these chambers will inflate or deflate to make the mattress firmer or softer. Sleepers control this firmness through remotes that are attached to the sides of the mattress. With just the push of a button, the mattress inflates and deflates!

It is worth noting that both sides of the mattress have their own remote. This means that partners can each control their side of the mattress! If one partner prefers a firmer mattress, and the other prefers something softer, it is no problem!

The mattress also works well with the Saatva Lineal adjustable base. This allows sleepers to raise or lower both the head and foot of the mattress.

Up, down, firm, or soft – the Saatva Solaire puts you in control.

What We Love About the Saatva Solaire

• The adjustability of the Solaire makes this a great buy for couples who have different ideas of what’s comfortable. In Queen-size mattresses and larger, firmness is adjustable on both sides of the bed.
• Couples will also appreciate the motion isolation in the Solaire, which minimizes potential disruptions from a partner moving in the night.
• The Solaire also offers good edge support. That’s an important consideration for people who have a hard time getting in and out of bed.

What to Keep in Mind About the Saatva Solaire

• Adjustability comes at a premium! With a queen mattress starting close to $4,500 before discounts, the Saatva Soliare is pricey.
• While the mattress is made with gel-infused foam, air chambers can trap heat. Hot sleepers may find they overheat too much on the Solaire and should consider a better cooling mattress.
• Heavyweight side sleepers may find the mattress lacks the softness they need around the hips and shoulders, even at soft settings. The Saatva HD mattress is worth a closer look.

Other User Reviews

On the Saatva website, the Solaire has no shortage of fans, earning a 4.7 out of 5-star rating. Reviewers praise the mattress for its adjustability and comfort, and many also mention the excellent customer service they’ve enjoyed.

Read the full Saatva Solaire mattress review for more information. Or check out our list of Most Comfortable Mattresses for more great options.

Read More

Best Customizable Cooling Mattress – Eight Sleep Pod Pro

Pros of the Eight Sleep Pod Pro

One of the best cooling mattresses on the market

Individual temperature control on both side of the bed

Built-in tracker for sleep insights

Cons of the Eight Sleep Pod Pro

High price point

Not supportive enough for heavier sleepers

Doesn’t isolation motion well

When it comes to sleeping hot and cold, everyone is different. Some people might wake up every night drenched in sweat while others can’t get warm, no matter what they do. Anyone who wants a mattress to help regulate their temperature during the night may want to take a look at the Eight Sleep Pod Pro.

The Eight Sleep Pod Pro is one of the most unique mattresses on the market today. That’s because it is more than just a mattress – it is a mattress plus a computer and high-tech cover. Simply put, the Hub (computer) pumps cool or warm water into the cover to cool or warm sleepers during the night. Using the app, people can set the mattress to whatever temperature they desire.

What’s more, each side of the mattress can be adjusted separately. This means that partners can each make their side of the mattress as cool or warm as they like.

If sleeping hot or cold is a major issue, find the right temperature with the Eight Sleep Pod Pro. It’s important to note that you can currently only buy the Eight Sleep mattress with the purchase of a Pod cover.

What We Love About the Eight Sleep Pod Pro

• This high-tech, luxury mattress is all about customized sleep. It has a hub that acts as both a computer and a pump to cool and warm the water in the mattress’s grid for complete temperature control.
• The tech features of the Eight Sleep mattress are easy to use, and people should have no trouble setting their preferences.
• The Active Grid and Hub track analytics including heart rate, breathing, and sleep cycles. There’s also an alarm feature that’s a nice alternative to traditional buzzing clocks.

What to Keep in Mind About the Eight Sleep Pod Pro

• The high-tech features of the Eight Sleep Pod Pro mean a higher price tag.
• It’s a bouncier mattress, so those looking for a mattress to isolate motion should consider one designed for couples.
• Edge support is lacking in the Eight Sleep mattress, which may be an issue for couples who need to maximize the sleep surface.

Other User Reviews

Thousands of reviewers credit the Eight Sleep for improving their sleep. Reviews mention the data and analytics, excellent customer service, and the sleep benefits of automatic temperature adjustments.

Read the full Eight Sleep Pod Pro mattress review for more information. Or check out our list of Best Cooling Mattresses for more great options.

Read More

What Are the Benefits of a Customizable Mattress?

At first glance, the benefits of a customizable mattress might seem obvious: Duh, you can customize it! But let’s take a closer look at how the ability to personalize the firmness, feel, and materials of a bed could provide real benefits.

Easy to Find a Good Fit

For starters, customization takes some guesswork out of the process of purchasing a mattress. Instead of picking a generic mattress and hoping it will feel comfortable in a preferred sleeping position(s), a customizable mattress offers major peace of mind. For instance, there’s no need to worry about whether it will accommodate the sleeper’s body weight, feel soft enough for side sleeping, or feel supportive enough for back and stomach sleeping, because it’s possible to select an option that’s tailor-made to the needs of the sleeper(s) in question.

Multiple Options in One Mattress

Some customizable mattresses allow for the option of getting multiple firmnesses in one bed thanks to a flippable or zip-off design. This means there’s no need to commit to a single sleeping position in order to feel comfortable. Let’s say someone’s in the mood to sleep on their back one night even though they normally sleep on their side. Or maybe they’ve always been a back sleeper but they’re wanting to transition to side sleeping. No problem! Simply select the appropriate firmness of the mattress to match the desired position.

Coping with Injury

Customizable mattresses that offer multiple firmness options can be helpful for anyone who’s dealing with an injury. For instance, if someone has injured their back and they only feel comfortable lying face-down on a firm surface, they can use the firmest version of the bed to maintain spinal support while stomach sleeping until their injury has healed. Same goes for folks who deal with chronic pain conditions: If they’re having a pain flare-up, they can flip to the softer side to cushion achy joints.

Make sure to also look at our best mattresses for neck and shoulder pain.

Good for Couples

Customizable mattresses can be a real boon for couples with different sleep styles. Some customizable mattresses allow users to independently select the firmness and feel of each side of the bed, so each person can achieve their definition of comfort. (These are often referred to as “split mattresses.”)

Another perk for couples? Customizable split mattresses can cut down on motion transfer. This is great news for anyone who sleeps with a restless partner and doesn’t want to be disturbed during the night.

Materials Preferences

Some people are allergic to various materials that are commonly used in mattresses (such as latex), while others are committed to investing in materials with a small eco-footprint (such as wool or natural latex). No matter a person’s preferences or needs, a customizable mattress could provide the option to construct a bed with or without particular materials.

Sizes And Shapes

Some people purchase customizable mattresses for the chance to select an unusually sized or shaped bed. For instance, some companies offer round or square options (and even the occasional heart shape), while others sell mattresses in sizes that are meant to fit RVs, boats, and other unusual sleeping spaces.

Cooling

One final benefit of customizable mattresses? They generally allow shoppers to select from a variety of cooling design features. This is great news for anyone who’s prone to sleeping hot and wants to ensure that their mattress helps them sleep cool.

What Are the Downsides of a Customizable Mattress?

With so many benefits to customizable mattresses, it might seem like there aren’t any downsides. And truly, we can’t think of many!

But there is one notable issue with customizable mattresses: They tend to be expensive. Folks who can afford the price of admission will enjoy plenty of return on their investment in the form of a mattress that’s tailor-made to their sleep space, preferences, and needs. But these beds simply aren’t affordable for everyone.

One other possible downside? With so many options to choose from, some people might find themselves experiencing decision fatigue while trying to craft the perfect mattress. All those choices represent lots of opportunity, but they can also be overwhelming.

RELATED: Best Mattress for Under $1000

What to Look for in a Customizable Mattress

Because customizable mattresses present shoppers with tons of choices, we’ve put together a list of factors to inform the purchasing process.

• Preferred sleeping position(s). As with any mattress purchase, the preferred sleeping position of the sleeper(s) in question will dictate the best firmness and feel for the bed. For instance, side sleepers will generally prefer a softer mattress that cushions their shoulder and hip; back sleepers generally benefit from plenty of spinal support combined with a touch of pressure relief; and those who need the best mattress for stomach sleepers require something extra-supportive to keep their hips elevated and aligned with the spine.
• Bodyweight. A person’s body weight has a big impact on their perception of a bed’s firmness, and it also dictates what’s required in terms of support. As a general rule, lighter weight folks tend to find a lot of mattresses softer than heavier folks, who are more likely to press through a bed’s comfort layers and into the firmer support layer(s) underneath. Additionally, those who need the best mattress for heavy people should look for a more supportive, durable mattress that won’t sag, such as an innerspring mattress.
• Firmness. We’ve touched on firmness in the previous bullets, but it warrants its own consideration. The firmness of a mattress will have a major impact on its feel, so it’s important to think about the body weight and preferred sleeping position(s) of everyone who will be using the mattress before selecting a firmness. Also consider whether it might be useful to purchase a bed that comes with two firmness options in one.
• Cooling. Some people are prone to overheating, and they’ll want to include cooling features in their customizable mattress. Popular options include coils (which allow for airflow through a mattress), perforated or gel-infused memory foam, and latex, which is known for sleeping cool.
• Partners. If the mattress in question will sleep more than one person, it’s important to take both partner’s preferences into account. Consider purchasing a customizable split mattress, which allows partners to tailor each side of the mattress individually.
• Height. Some people prefer the elegant look of a tall mattress and will want to customize their mattress height accordingly. On the other hand, folks with mobility issues will probably prefer to select a shorter mattress, which should make it easier to climb in and out of bed.
• Size and shape. Most customizable mattresses will come in the full range of conventional sizes, from Twin to King or California King. In some cases, it’s also possible to customize the shape of the bed. Consider the sleeper’s preferences around size and shape while customizing the mattress.
• Adjustability. Note that customizability and adjustability are not interchangeable terms in the mattress world. An adjustable mattress is one that can move with an adjustable base in order to raise or lower certain sections of the bed (such as the head and foot). If this is appealing, make sure to look for a customizable mattress that offers adjustability.
• Price. As with any mattress purchase, it’s essential to consider budget. In general, customizable mattresses tend to be on the pricier side. So if finances are tight, think about which features are essential and which are negotiable in order to land on a customizable mattress that’s both comfortable and affordable. Also, take a look at our best mattresses for the money.
• Company policies. Before investing in a customizable mattress, review the policies of the company in question. Take note of the warranty, sleep trial, return policies, and so on to avoid any surprises down the road.

Best Customizable Mattress Types

It probably won’t come as a surprise that customizable mattresses represent a wide range of mattress types. After all, the whole point of these beds is to optimize choice! All those options pose the question: Which customizable mattress type is best?
There’s no singular “best” mattress type when it comes to customizable mattresses, but there are better options for different types of sleepers. Here’s a quick look at some of the most popular mattress types.

Innerspring

An innerspring mattress incorporates springs (or coils) into its support layer. This generally creates a responsive, bouncy, and supportive feel and produces a durable mattress. The supportive nature of these mattresses could be ideal for back and stomach sleepers looking to maintain proper spinal alignment. A mattress with coils is also a good option for heavier weight sleepers, who need a more supportive bed.

In the customizable mattress space, many brands offer the option of selecting an innerspring mattress with a pillow top on top, which provides some room to customize the firmness level and plushness of the mattress. In addition, it is a good idea to check out our best innerspring mattresses.

Memory Foam

Memory foam mattresses are generally very pressure-relieving, because the material contours a sleeper’s body and cushions pressure points such as the shoulders or hips. Because of this, they are often the best mattresses for side sleepers.

The firmness of a memory foam mattress can vary dramatically depending on the number and thickness of its comfort layers as well as the material used in the support layer. Many memory foam beds have a base layer made from firmer polyfoam, which helps support the hips and spine.

Memory foam has a tendency to trap heat, so hot sleepers who are interested in a memory foam mattress will want to customize it with cooling features such as gel infusions, perforated foam, and/or a breathable cover.

Hybrid

A hybrid mattress combines supportive coils with comfort layers made from materials such as memory foam, wool, or latex. Because they balance comfort and support, hybrid mattresses tend to accommodate a wide range of sleepers. Hybrids are popular in the customizable mattress space, because there’s lots of room to select various coils, comfort layers, materials, and so on.

Latex

Latex mattresses are produced from either natural or synthetic latex. Both options tend to produce a mattress that’s bouncy, durable, and a touch pressure relieving. Because latex mixes bounciness with some body contouring, it can work well for both back and side sleepers, who need a balance of spinal support and pressure relief.

Natural latex is a fairly eco-friendly material, so it can be a great option for folks who are looking to customize a natural bed. Latex also creates a cool sleeping environment.

Airbed

No, we’re not talking about those blow-up air mattresses that deflate during sleep. Instead, airbeds are luxury mattresses that feature a support core composed of adjustable air chambers. In many cases, this support core is layered under a comfort layer made from foam or latex (buyer’s choice).

Airbeds allow sleepers to personalize the firmness of their bed on a nightly basis, making these beds the ultimate in customization. Not only can sleepers tailor the mattress to their preferences prior to purchase, but they can continue to tweak the firmness and feel of the bed based on their nightly preferences. However, this luxury tends to come at a steep price.

Tips For Getting The Most Out Of A Customizable Mattress

Customizing a mattress involves plenty of time and thought as well as a chunk of change. To make the most of a customizable mattress purchase, implement the following guidelines.

• Spend time testing different options. Most people haven’t slept on every mattress type available, so some people simply won’t know whether they like the feel of latex, wool, hybrids, or other materials and constructions. Before investing in a customizable mattress, try to test out all the options available by going to mattress showrooms or spending some time on the beds of friends with different mattress types. Aim to spend at least 15 to 20 minutes on a mattress and try out different sleep positions to get a feel for the material in question.
• Ask the brand for suggestions. After selecting a mattress brand to buy from, don’t be afraid to ask questions. The company has probably worked with tons of other sleepers, so they should have an idea of what might work best based on other people’s experiences.
• Review trial and return policies. While many online mattress brands offer long sleep trials, this might not be the case for customizable beds because they’re so personalized. Before making a purchase, make sure to review the trial and return policies to know whether it’s an irreversible commitment.
• Take good care of the mattress. Hopefully, all of the thought and time that went into customizing a mattress has paid off in the form of a comfortable bed that promotes quality sleep. After purchasing a customizable mattress, make sure to take good care of it so it lasts as long as possible. Rotate or flip the mattress every few months (depending on its construction), clean it regularly, use a mattress protector, and keep food and drinks out of the bed to ensure it stays in good shape for years to come.

Customizable Mattress FAQs